It was a pleasure working with Sue Sherman-Broyles and Colleen Nash on our transaction. They worked well as a team to answer fully all our questions and help us during the closing process.


Sue was excellent. She knew all the answers to the questions we had. She always responded to our texts and emails in a timely manner. Due to multiple offers, we had to go higher than the listing price. Sue helped us with her knowledge of the process to stay within a reasonable price.


She has been so awesome to us! I can’t thank her enough for all the traveling she’s done for me and for helping us find our forever home! Out in the country what I’ve been looking for! She also has great communication. Thank you, Sue!

M. Stilwell

It was closing from hell. Our agent preserved and kept a cool head and helped keep us calm during the process.

M. Stilwell

It was closing from hell. Our agent preserved and kept a cool head and helped keep us calm during the process

E. Kiriny and S. Jackson

Sue was great and very personable. On the ball and answered questions promptly. One of the best Realtor that I’ve worked with and I’ve dealt with quite a few.

B. Kelly

We could not ask for a better realtor. Sue has done a remarkable job for us. We had to do the entire purchase remotely due to our ability to travel. Sue provided a wonderful experience from reviewing properties to closing, and even after closing. Sue has been extremely helpful with every step of the transaction. She has great knowledge of the area, and she has a great access to resources to help address any issue. I would highly recommend utilizing Sue as your Realtor. She is absolutely outstanding.

D. Larison

I would highly recommend Susan to anyone looking to sell or buy. She is extremely knowledgeable and supportive.

L. Eierman

Sue is amazing! In this hot seller’s market, she helped us buy our dream home by getting us in the door before any other buyers and helping us put a reasonable offer immediately on the table. She guided us every step of the way. I would 100% recommend Sue as your realtor.


Sue is a gem in the real estate business… avid listener, extremely sharp, very competent and eager to follow the direction of her client. You can’t go wrong!

R. Pitoniak

Sue was a great resources and very responsive to questions and concerns. I would highly recommend working with Sue.

K. Tobin

Sue is great to work with. She is responsive and always on top of the next step you need to take. She kept us up to date on what was happening in the closing process so we never had to wonder and worked hard to keep the closing moving along-even through a pandemic which was slowing so many businesses down. I would highly recommend booking Sue to help you sell your home.

rsd adirondack

Sue represented me in the sale of a building lot in the Adirondack Mountains. She did a fantastic job representing my interests, moved things along quickly, and was an excellent communicator! I would highly recommend Sue Sherman-Broyles!


Sue has been a great agent. She responds quickly when I have questions which are nice since I’m buying from so far away. Sue has helped me connect with people I needed to complete the purchase process. I wouldn’t hesitate to use her again if needed in the future.

Sara Ryan

Sue has been extremely helpful and responsive. We are first time homebuyers and moving from out of state and Sue has gone above and beyond to help us in the home buying process. I would recommend her to anyone looking to move to or buy a new home in the Cortland area!


Sue is an excellent realtor. She was patient and knowledgeable throughout the buying process. I felt that Sue truly cared about helping us find the right home. She was supportive of our decisions and never made us feel pressured to settle for a home we disliked. Her honesty and attention to detail helped us avoid homes that weren’t right for us and end up with a home that we love! Sue was prompt in responding to our questions and requests for tours. Her guidance made the complex buying process easy to manage. Sue came highly recommended to us by a colleague; we, too, will recommend her to others.


Sue is professional, honest, and caring. She is highly intelligent and hardworking with outstanding research skills, valuable for a realtor. She helped us sell a unique property, in a rural area during the pandemic. Her communication skills are excellent and she’s not afraid to say I don’t know, but I’ll find out.

Mike B.

“Sue Sherman-Broyles is the type of person who starts out as a real estate agent and, within a cup of coffee, it feels like she’s your lifelong friend. She’s smart, she’s dedicated and, above all, she cares deeply about people. She also has her finger on the pulse of Cortland — both the college and the local community. My wife and I had high expectations in search of our first home and, through her connections, Sue helped us find a once-in-a-lifetime house to raise a young family. We’re fortunate to call Cortland our home. Friends like Sue are a big reason why.”

Barry Batzing

If you are considering the sale of a property, or the purchase of a property, you can be assured that Sue will meet the specific needs and goals you are seeking! My wife and I have known Sue since 1992 through her work at SUNY Cortland, as a YWCA board member and past president, and as a dedicated member of Lime Hollow Nature Center. Through her many affiliations in the area and her personal interactions among an extensive range of individuals, she maintains a broad familiarity of the community. She has always been well-liked and admired in all settings.

Being a goal-oriented and an especially organized individual, Sue focuses on particular requirements by attending to specific details. We’ve all known clients who have switched realtors because contact has dwindled and they feel neglected by a non-attentive broker at a time when you really need to sell or buy as soon as possible! That is why, when the time comes for us to downsize, Sue will be OUR choice as realtor.